Posted by
mordred
on July 29, 2006 at 03:47 PM
I was just listening to a song on my iPod. I have a lot of them, so I really only hear things when I listen on shuffle. The song Breathe (2AM) by Anna Nalick came on. It's a good song. Anna has a little ways to go before she's Tori Amos or Sarah McLaughlin, but she's moving in that direction. The thing that jumped out at me was the third verse (the one after the bridge - standard pop structure, you know.)
2 AM and I'm still awake, writing a song
If I get it all down on paper, it's no longer inside of me,
Threatening the life it belongs to
And I feel like I'm naked in front of the crowd
Cause these words are my diary, screaming out loud
And I know that you'll use them, however you want to
It seems like just another song about a songwriter writing songs. And it is. It's not a manifesto on modern copyright law or economics. Except that to me it sums up my side of the argument just fine. The powers that be tell us that without strong copywright protection in the form of DRM and content control, the industry will fold and we will be without new art to enjoy. But Anna betrays the real truth in her song. She's writing the song (ostensibly, if we believe what she says) because she has to. Internally, she has no choice but to write the song. By singing it in front of a crowd of people, she feels totally open and naked - she's baring her soul... Then the kicker - she recognizes that our relationship to the song is not hers to control. No matter what she does, we will interact with the song in our own way. It may be meaningful, we may hate it - we may turn it in to an essay on the evils of DRM.
Will a lack of content control hurt the production of art? No. Not at all. Will it make artists less rich? Probably. So what. The law doesn't and shouldn't exist to ensure that certain individuals get wealthy. That's for the free market to decide. It's also not for a corporation to decide how I interact with art. It's not for the artist to decide. It's not for the playwright to decide how the play is directed. It's not for the musician to decide how my soul is moved. Of course, the people in charge of corporations have no idea about any of this, because there probably isn't anything they do because something welling up from the bottom of their soul forces them to. They would have to have a sould first.